7 Best Neighborhoods in Colts Neck: Where to Live in Colts Neck NJ (2024)

Colts Neck Township, NJ, often celebrated for its picturesque landscapes and a unique blend of historical and modern Monmouth County homes, offers an array of neighborhoods to cater to various budgets and tastes. From opulent estates to more modestly priced areas, homebuyers moving to Colts Neck enjoy access to a wide range of housing options. This article delves into the finest neighborhoods in the area, highlighting what makes them among the best.

Orchard Estates

Orchard Estates includes around two dozen luxury homes on the shores of the westernmost reaches of Swimming River Reservoir, just a short drive from the heart of Colts Neck. Residents enjoy gorgeous views of the water or nearby farmland, with no rear neighbors for any property.

Mature landscaping also provides privacy from neighbors. Owners can get out and see more Colts Neck nature at the nearby Dorbrook Recreation Area—one of Colts Neck’s best parks—which includes trails, sports courts, a splash park, and a large, unique playground known as Challenger Place. They can also hit the links at one of several golf clubs close to the neighborhood, like Pebble Creek Golf Club. It's also convenient to the Garden State Parkway, making everything from the best of North Jersey to the top Shore destinations an easy drive away.

Homes in Orchard Estates are exclusively high-end single-family detached homes, generally including four or five bedrooms and around 4,000 to 7,000 square feet of living space. Most were built in the late 1980s but have been continually updated and improved in the decades since. Nearly every home has a swimming pool and outdoor entertaining space, filling just a small part of lots that reach up to an acre and a half. Properties start around $1.3 million and reach $2.5 million or more.

Hills Gait

Hills Gait is a small development of a few looping streets just off Boundary Road near Big Brook Park. This nearby park space is among the community's best features, spanning more than 430 acres and offering amenities like hiking and biking trails, an outdoor swimming pool, and ideal spots for wildlife watching and fossil hunting.

This leafy, agricultural character continues throughout the surrounding area, like at 4JG Orchards & Vineyards, where locally grown grapes are crafted into fine wines that guests can enjoy at tastings and other events. Hills Gait also provides easy access to the amenities and services in nearby communities like Holmdel.

Hills Gait’s selection of single-family homes in Colts Neck generally includes four to six bedrooms and up to five bathrooms spread over 3,500 to 6,000 square feet or more of living space. Extensive lots provide plenty of room for swimming pools and extensive privacy from neighbors and nearby roads.

Much of the surrounding area is protected as part of Big Brook Nature Preserve, ensuring the community won't lose its quiet, rural character. Homes in Hills Gait start at just under $1 million and can reach $1.4 million or more.

Carriage Hill

Carriage Hill is another top Colts Neck neighborhood—located along the town's western border. This quiet community of just a few dozen homes features farmland, horse boarding and training facilities, and some of the major schools in Colts Neck.

However, State Route 18 is also close by, offering one of the best options for traveling throughout Central New Jersey and along the shore. In addition, Carriage Hill is close to one of Colts Neck's best parks, Bucks Mill Recreation Area. This gorgeous facility includes a community center, sports fields, picnic areas, horse facilities, hiking trails, and more.

Residents can also enjoy a diverse selection of restaurants, including local favorites like Cuzin's Seafood and Clam Bar and Fireside Grill and Bar.

These stylish, classic single-family detached homes, constructed in the 1970s, vary widely from cozy three-bedroom ranches to sprawling luxury homes with six or seven bedrooms and upwards of 5,500 square feet. Spacious lots of an acre to an acre and a half offer room for swimming pools and other outdoor features. Homes in Carriage Hill most commonly sell for anywhere from mid-$800s to just under $1.4 million.

Clover Hill

Clover Hill is larger and more spread out than many other Colts Neck neighborhoods, bounded by Newman Springs Road to the north, Route 34 to the east, and Boundary Road to the west.

This places it just across the road from Big Brook Park's extensive green spaces and trails. While the area is primarily residential, there are also nearby restaurant options like The Polo Club and Prima Pizza along Route 34. The services and amenities of Holmdel Township are also relatively close by, as are a number of businesses, restaurants, and medical facilities near Route 79 and Newman Springs Road.

This expansive community hosts an equally extensive selection of single-family detached homes. It's a hilly area interspersed with mature, privacy-friendly woods that hug small streams. Some unique properties date back to the 1950s, others are newer constructions built within the last few years, and sizes range from around 2,000 to 5,000 square feet.

On the low end, homes for sale in Clover Hill list from the low $700s, with typical options selling in the $1–$2 million range. However, ultraluxury properties can sometimes reach as much as twice that amount.

The Grande

The Grande hugs Colts Neck's southwestern corner—between Colts Neck Road and Stone Hill/Burlington Road. It consists of clusters of homes built along about a dozen cul-de-sacs, short dead-end streets, and loops. This unique design makes the moderately sized community feel more intimate, allowing neighbors to get to know one another.

Golfers will love their new home thanks to their proximity to the 18-hole Hominy Hill Golf Course, one of Colts Neck’s best golf courses. It's been rated the state's top public course and offers an on-site pro shop and restaurant for hungry locals. Numerous small parks and green spaces are also close by. In addition, Freehold Township is just a few minutes down the road, including the cluster of local restaurants and shops on Main Street, like Federici's Family Restaurant and Court Jester.

Most of the single-family detached homes in The Grande include three or four bedrooms and two-and-a-half to three-and-a-half bathrooms in layouts ranging from 2,000 to 3,000 square feet. High-end interior features like walk-out basem*nts, wood-burning fireplaces, and granite countertops complement beautifully landscaped lots with decks or screened porches. While each owner has put their personal touches on the homes, their relative similarity means they sell in a tight range from the mid-$500s to the low-$800s, which makes The Grande one of Colts Neck’s more affordable neighborhoods.

Due Process Estates

The unusually named Due Process Estates takes its moniker from the adjacent Due Process Stables Golf Course, one of the Garden State's best private courses. The small number of Colts Neck luxury homes that make up the community sit west of the course off Hockhockson Road. Extra spacious lots are typical of this high-end neighborhood, ranging from around two acres to as much as 12.

The green space continues nearby, with Dorbrook Recreation Area across the road, filled with amenities from splash parks and playgrounds to picnic sites and hiking trails. Despite this green, idyllic atmosphere, residents can hop on the Garden State Parkway in just minutes, providing easy access to the best of New Jersey.

Mostly built in the early 2000s, homes provide five to seven bedrooms throughout beautifully finished, spacious properties of 5,500 to more than 13,100 square feet. Each also includes a private swimming pool, and while interiors can vary depending on the tastes of the original owners of these custom homes, they invariably feature some of the area's finest layouts and finishes.

Due to the low number of properties, homes in Due Process Estates typically hit the market less frequently but can sell for a broad range from $2 to $5 million when they do.

Phalanx Farms

The community of Phalanx Farms sits on a peninsula in the Swimming River Reservoir in northeastern Colts Neck. Many of these high-end homes offer the views and privacy provided by direct waterfront locations.

Meanwhile, the heart of the Lincroft community is just across the water in Middletown Township, including shops and restaurants like Charlie's of Lindcroft and Attilio's Villagio Restaurant & Pizzeria. The area is also home to nearby Brookdale Community College, which offers a variety of affordable college degrees and certificates. In addition, Phalanx Farms is one of the closest Colts Neck communities to top Jersey Shore destinations like Long Branch and hip, vibrant towns like Red Bank.

Phalanx Farms' single-family detached homes—most of which are classified as Monmouth County luxury homes—range from three to six bedrooms, covering vast square footage ranging from just over 2,000 to more than 9,000. Some well-kept properties date back to the 1970s, while others are more recent. This produces a variety of homes suitable for nearly any buyer's space needs or tastes. The community's older or more modestly sized properties start in the high six figures to around $1 million. Newer or larger homes for sale in Phalanx Farms generally top out in the $1.5–$2 million range, with some even available just under $6 million.

Sought-After Corners of Colts Neck

Throughout Colts Neck Township, the distinct neighborhoods each carry a charm that resonates with their respective price tags. From the grandeur of the most expensive areas to the serene appeal of the affordable sections, there's a place for every budget in this stunning town. Aspiring residents and curious readers alike can glean an understanding of the unique tapestry of Colts Neck's residential areas, appreciating the vibrancy each neighborhood brings to the community.