Instant Pot Polenta Recipe - Rachel Cooks® (2024)

Love polenta but don’t have time to do all that stirring? Instant Pot polenta is beautifully creamy and delicious, and so easy to make!

This creamy golden polenta is the stuff of dreams. Well, perhaps only food bloggers dream about food but you know what I mean. Polenta is comfort food whether you enjoy it regularly or as a special treat.

Now that I know how easy it is to make polenta in an Instant Pot, I think it will be making an appearance on my table a lot more often. And why not? It’s economical, filling, and nutritious. It’s basically a cereal, just ground up corn, and you can store it in your pantry, refrigerator, or freezer pretty much indefinitely. It’s gluten-free, too.

And it’s delicious! Enjoy creamy polenta just plain, or topped with any type of sauce, sautéed vegetable, or meat. For a truly special meal, polenta is divine with red wine braised short ribs or lamb shanks. Refrigerate polenta until it’s firm, and it can be lightly fried in olive oil for a completely different treat.

I’ve heard that polenta is the Italian version of mashed potatoes. I’m not sure if that’s true or not but I totally get that. Give this easy recipe a try and see what you think!

P.S. Be sure to try Instant Pot risotto, another Italian favorite. We also love roasted mushroom risotto which is made on the stovetop.

About This Polenta Recipe

Instant Pot polenta is almost embarrassingly easy. Water, cornmeal, butter, and salt is all you need. How do these humble ingredients magically turn into something so creamy and delicious?

Well, I don’t know. Let’s just consider it one of life’s mysteries. I will say, once you make polenta in your Instant Pot, you’ll never cook it any other way.

If you’re a traditionalist, maybe you’ll resist using this recipe. Perhaps all the stirring is part of the satisfaction of making your own. I challenge you to try Instant Pot polenta just once. Just once! I think you’ll be convinced.

I’ll get you started here with an overview of the recipe and extra tips. Look for specific measurements, instructions, and nutrition information on the recipe card below.

What You’ll Need

• Polenta: Polenta is technically a dish made with coarsely ground cornmeal. If you buy cornmeal that’s labeled “polenta,” you can be sure that it’s the best grind for making polenta. Finely ground cornmeal won’t have the best texture; your polenta will be too pasty. Don’t buy instant polenta; it won’t work in this recipe.
• Kosher Salt: If you’re using salted broth or including the cheese, you may want to decrease the amount of added salt. In addition, kosher salt has coarse grains which means that not as much fits in a teaspoon. If you choose table salt, you’ll want to decrease the amount.
• Water or Broth: Unsalted chicken broth enhances the flavor of the polenta but classic polenta is made with water.
• Butter: Choose unsalted butter, not butter spreads or the like.
• Parmesan or Pecorino Cheese: Cheese is optional but I think you’ll agree, it makes your polenta super tasty.
• Freshly Cracked Black Pepper, to taste

How to make Instant Pot Polenta

It’s so easy! I may have said that already, but really, it is!

Simply measure out one cup of polenta in a dry measuring cup. Level off the cup with a straight edge, such as a table knife. Pour it into the pot.

Next, measure out 4 cups of liquid, either water or broth, and add it to the pot. It seems like a lot but don’t worry.

Add salt and stir the three ingredients together. Cover the pressure cooker, locking to seal.

Set to Pressure Cook, or High Pressure, depending on the model you have. Set the time for 9 minutes. It will take roughly 11 minutes to come to pressure.

When the timer goes off, let the pressure release naturally for ten minutes. That means you don’t do anything other than keep on eye on the time. I usually set a timer because it’s easy to forget about it.

Once ten minutes has elapsed, release any remaining pressure and carefully remove the lid.

Using a sturdy whisk, vigorously stir the polenta until it’s creamy. It will look quite watery at first and you may think this recipe is a flop but keep stirring and wait for the magic to occur.

After a couple of minutes, the polenta will start to come together. Stir in the butter and whisk until the butter melts. Stir in the cheese, and season with freshly cracked black pepper.

Serve the polenta immediately, garnished with fresh herbs if desired. Polenta continues to thicken as it cools.

If it gets too thick before you serve it, whisk in a bit of hot broth or water to thin the consistency a bit.

What To Serve With Polenta

Polenta is quite versatile. I love it for breakfast with a soft cooked fried egg and sautéed spinach. Most pasta sauces can be served on polenta but don’t stop there. Here are a few recipes you may enjoy:

• Slow cooker Italian pot roast: You’ll love the flavor of this pot roast and the melt-in-your mouth tender beef. Polenta is a traditional side with Italian pot roast.
• Homemade spaghetti sauce: The longer this sauce simmers, the better it gets!
• Turkey Bolognese: Made with ground turkey and turkey sausage, this sauce has loads of fresh herbs and just a bit of cream.
• Spicy garlic shrimp: Creamy polenta is a perfect counterpoint to the spicy shrimp.
• Creamy Tuscan mushrooms: Oh my, this is a match made in heaven!
• Sautéed greens such as baby kale, spinach, or beet greens. Saute the greens in a generous amount of olive oil, add garlic and a pinch of red pepper flakes.
• Air fryer sweet potato hash: The candied bacon in this mix really takes it up a notch. Actually, any medley of roasted vegetables are great on polenta. These balsamic roasted vegetables are a great choice, too.
• Instant Pot short ribs or red wine braised short ribs

FAQs

Make It Your Own

• Vegan: Make it vegan by omitting the butter and cheese. If you like, vegan butter and cheese can be substituted. You can add more flavor by using a vegetable broth or adding a tablespoon or two of nutritional yeast.
• Make it with milk. Replace a cup of the water with one cup of milk, if desired.

Storage & Reheating Tips

Refrigerate: Cover polenta that’s left over with plastic wrap, or put it into an airtight container. Refrigerate for up to 5 days. Polenta will solidify when chilled.

Freeze: It can also be frozen for a few months. Thaw overnight in the fridge before reheating.

Reheat: Warm individual portions of polenta in the microwave, with medium power. Stir a couple of times to loosen it up. If it’s too thick, thin it with a bit of water, milk, or broth. Larger portions can be heated in a saucepan or skillet. See the section below for another idea.

Interested in a weekly meal plan (it’s free!) that includes this polenta recipe? Take a look at my Meal Plan (#4). You’ll find a wholesome recipe for each weekday plus a categorized grocery list. Let me do the planning for you this week!

We’ll be adding a new meal plan weekly. If you’re interested, browse all of our meal plans.

Leftover Love

Leftover polenta will become quite solid once it’s chilled. Smooth it into a pan or shape it into a log before refrigerating it. Once it’s completely chilled, polenta can be sliced and fried in a bit of olive oil. Serve the fried slices with a spoonful of warm marinara and a handful of grated cheese. Add a side dish of roasted broccoli for a very satisfying meal.

Try this rustic polenta stack, with fried polenta, marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella slices, and fresh basil. Sliced polenta can be used to make this favorite one pan meal: Sheet pan Italian sausage, polenta, and broccoli.